Rohana Sinaga, Harmein Nasution, Nazaruddin Matondang


PT PTPN IV (PTPN IV) as one of the state-owned enterprises (SOEs) has made the transformation, including in terms of human resource management. This is reflected in a transformation program which has been launched by the Board of Directors PTPN IV, namely: human resources as the most important asset that must be transformed into a level of qualification that is recognized universally, in the aspects of competence, capability and integrity. To increase knowledge (knowledge), skills (skills) and attitude (attitude) to fit the demands of the post, periodically HR should be given education and training means that the education and training of human resources is an investment that can be interpreted by issuing a number of funds. Evaluation of training can be used as a measuring tool to help identify and analyze the training benefit significantly, demonstrating clear returns for the company, as the basis for evaluation of the training system during this time so that it can be improved in order to contribute to the training of the company. Significant changes occur on the competence of the ex-trainee aircraft operator on duty at the boiler palm oil mill PT PTPN IV, after they followed the training. This is evident from the average value of the competence of the former participants of the training changes are relatively high at 4.27 (good category) of the three domains of competence studied, the greatest changes occur is on the domain of skills of participants increased quality of the work with a score of 4, 44 followed by Attitudes that increased motivation with a score of 4.40, respectively. Return on Training Investment (ROTI), obtained BREAD value of 420%.

Keywords: Return on Training Investment (ROTI), training, education, evaluation.

Full Text:



Almeida, Rita (2008).The Return to Firm Investments in Human Capital. SP Discussion Paper No. 0822. Social Protection & Labor, The World Bank.

Anonymus (2005). 5 Creative ways to Measure Training Return on Invesment.IOMA’S Report on Managing Training & Develovment, 3,1-3

Barker, Kathryn. (2002). Why Train? Calculating the Return on Training Investment. Open Learning Agency. Burnaby.

Bartel, Ann P. (2000). Measuring the Employer’s Return on Investments in Training: Evidence from Literature. Industrial Relations, Vol 39, No. 3 (july 2000).

Burns, Alvin C. and Bush, R.F. (2000). Marketing Research 3rd ed. Englewood Cliff, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall

Burrow,Jim & Berarnidelli, Paula (2003). Systematic Performance Improvement – Refining the Space Between Learning and Result. Journal of Workplace Learning ,15, 6-13

Carr,Wendy F.” Designing an Efective Training Evaluation Process”, SHRM White Paper, December 1999.

Cyrs, Thomas E. ( 1998). Evaluating Distance Learning Program and Courses Educational Develovment Associates, 3, 1-2

Farrel, Don G. (2005). What The ROI of Training Programs? Lodging Hospitality, 61, 46.

Fitz-enz,jac. (2000). ROI of Human Capital.New York: AMACOM, American Management Association.

Goldstein,Irwin (1993).”Training in Organizations : Needs Assesment, Development, and Evaluation.3rd ed. California:Brooks/cole/Publishing Company.

Gordon,Edward E” Training ROI” , Answering the Return on Invesment Puzle”, SHRM White Paper, August 1999.

Kirpatrick, Donald L. and Kirpatrick, J, D. (2006). Evaluating Training Programs. San Fransisico: Berret –Koehler.

Lilly, Frances.” Four Steps to Computing Training ROI”. SHRM White Paper, February 2001.

Lynch, Kara., Akridge, Jay T., Schaffer, Scott P. and Gray, Allan. (2006). A Framework for Evaluating Return on Investment in Management Development Programs1. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review. Volume 9, Issue 2, 2006

Noe, Raymond A. (2002). Employe Training and Development. 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill

Philips, Jack J. (1997). Return on Invesment in Training and Performance Improvement Programs. Houston : Gulf Publishing company

Sudjana (2008), (

Tupamahu, Stefan dan Soetjipto, Budi W. (2005). Pengukuran Return on Training Investment (ROTI). Lembaga Management, Fakultas Ekonomi Universitas Indonesia.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2018 Jurnal Optimalisasi

JOPT: Jurnal Optimalisasi Indexing and Abstracting by: